Authors
- Dorskaya Aleksandra Andreyevna Doctor of Law, Professor
- Dorskiy Andrey Yuryevich Doctor in Philosophy, Professor
Annotation
The article analyzes the development of such type of punishment as deportation to Siberia, showing that despite the visible gaps in the history of Russian law caused by radical changes in the form of the state, continuity can be maintained even in relation to those institutions of law that, at first glance, should be destroyed. This topic became the subject of study back in the 19th century, but at the present stage it has been updated due to a new stage of “experiencing history”, when the self-identification of states and peoples that were part of the Russian Empire or the Soviet Union is based on existing experience or is built on its denial.
The purpose of the study is to comprehensively characterize the exile to a settlement in Siberia as a punishment that arose in the 18th century and went through a significant transformation, including both breaks in the established tradition and continuity that arises in the most unexpected way. In accordance with the goal, the following tasks are set in the article such as to characterize the main stages in the evolution of exile to a settlement in Siberia as a type of criminal punishment, to identify the goals of criminal policy in relation to the development of this punishment, to show the place of exile to a settlement in Siberia in the system of criminal penalties of the Russian Empire, to identify the continuity of pre-revolutionary, Soviet and modern approaches in relation to the deportation to a settlement in its various forms. As a result of the work, using the example of deportation to a settlement in Siberia as a criminal punishment of the Russian Empire, the need to use the experience of different
eras in assessing modern reform projects is shown.
How to link insert
Dorskaya, A. A. & Dorskiy, A. Y. (2022). The Problem of Gaps and Continuity in the Development of Russian Law (on the Example of Deportation to Siberia) Bulletin of the Moscow City Pedagogical University. Series "Pedagogy and Psychology", 2022, №4 (48), 22. https://doi.org/10.25688/2076-9113.2022.48.4.02
References
1.
1. Arxipov S. V. Genezis instituta ssy`lki v mexanizme shtrafnoj kolonizacii vostochny` x okrain Rossii v XIX veke // Ugolovno-ispolnitel`naya sistema: realii i perspektivy` razvitiya: materialy` II Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii. Pskov: Pskovskij filial Akademii FSIN Rossii, 2020. S. 28–35.
2.
2. Arxipov S. V. Ustav o ssy`l`ny`x 1822 g. kak istochnik penitenciarnogo prava i ego rol` v realizacii kolonizacionnoj politiki Rossii v XIX v. // Vestnik Samarskogo yuridicheskogo instituta. 2015. № 2 (6). S. 14–17.
3.
3. Beshenczov A. N. Ssy`l`naya: roman v 2 ch. M.: Tipografiya Baxmeteva, 1866. 182 s.
4.
4. Gorelov V. N. Vmesto ssy`lki v Sibir` na poselenie… k otdache v voennuyu sluzhbu ryadovy`mi // Voenno-istoricheskij zhurnal. 2012. № 11. S. 51–55.
5.
5. Dolgix A. N. Ssy`lka krest`yan na poselenie v Sibir` po vole pomeshhikov v zakonodatel` stve Rossijskoj imperii // Rossijskaya istoriya. 2013. № 3. S. 74–84.
6.
6. Zaxarov V. P. Vlast` i obshhestvo: problemy` ssy`lki i pereseleniya // Vestnik Severo-Vostochnogo federal`nogo universiteta im. M. K. Ammosova. 2015. T. 12. № 2. S. 56–60.
7.
7. Kodan S. V. Politicheskaya ssy`lka v sisteme karatel`ny`x mer samoderzhaviya pervoj poloviny` XIX v. Irkutsk: Irkutskij gosudarstvenny`j universitet im. A. A. Zhdanova, 1980. 95 s.
8.
8. Korablin K. K. Russkaya ssy`lka v Sibir` v period s XVI do nachala XX stoletiya // Osnovny`e tendencii gosudarstvennogo i obshhestvennogo razvitiya Rossii: istoriya i sovremennost`. 2016. № 1. S. 18–31.
9.
9. Korablin K. K. Transformaciya nakazaniya v vide katorgi i ssy`lki v russkom prave (XIX – nachalo XX vv.) // Obrazovanie i pravo. 2020. № 10. S. 284–289.
10.
10. Kuzneczov V. I. Dostizhenie celi nakazaniya v ispravitel`ny`x centrax kak al`ternativa koloniyam poseleniyam // Yuridicheskie nauki, pravovoe gosudarstvo i sovremennoe zakonodatel`stvo: sbornik statej XIII Mezhdunarodnoj nauchno-prakticheskoj konferencii. Penza: Nauka i Prosveshhenie, 2020. S. 106–110.
11.
11. Moryakov E. Yu. Ssy`lka na poselenie v memuarax by`vshix krepostny`x // Lyudi imperii — imperiya lyudej: personal`naya i institucional`naya istoriya Aziatskix okrain Rossii. Sbornik nauchny`x statej. Omsk: Omskij gosudarstvenny`j universitet im. F. M. Dostoevskogo, 2021. S. 233–239.
12.
12. Nefedovskaya E. V. Reformy` rossijskoj ssy`lki v e`poxu Aleksandra I: soderzhanie i posledstviya // Sovremennaya nauchnaya my`sl`. 2014. № 1. S. 50–61.
13.
13. Salomon A. P. Ssy`lka v Sibir`. Ocherk ee istorii i sovremennogo polozheniya. SPb.: Tipografiya Sankt-Peterburgskoj tyur`my`, 1900. 53 s.
14.
14. Ssy`lka i katorga v Sibiri. XVIII – nachalo XX vv. Sbornik statej / otv. red. L. M. Goryushkin. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1975. 304 s.
15.
15. Ugolovno-ispolnitel`noe pravo: uchebnik / pod red. I. V. Shmarova. M.: Bek, 1996. 417 s.
16.
16. Uporov I. V. Ssy`lka na poselenie v Rossijskoj imperii: zakonodatel`noe regulirovanie i osobennosti ispolneniya (XVIII – nachalo XIX vekov) // Diskurs. 2019. № 3 (29). S. 6–13.
17.
17. Chatadzhyan A. G. Koloniya-poselenie kak vid ispravitel`nogo uchrezhdeniya v istorii rossijskogo zakonodatel`stva // Informacionny`e materialy` dlya studentov: sajt. URL: https://superinf.ru/view_helpstud.php?id=759 (data obrashheniya: 01.09.2022).
18.
18. Sheksheev A. P. «Kulaczkaya» ssy`lka na territorii Enisejskoj Sibiri (1929–1934 gg.) // Sibirskij arxiv. 2020. № 2 (4). S. 134–167.
19.
19. Shheglova T. K. E`tnicheskie deportacii v Altajskij kraj: e`tapy`, sostav, chislennost`, osobennosti razmeshheniya (1939–1956 gg.) // E`tnografiya Altaya i sopredel`ny`x territorij. 2020. № 10. S. 243–253.
20.
20. Volchetskaia T. S., Smirnov L. B., Shestakov D. A. Exile to settlement in Siberia in the criminal punishment system of the Russian empire in the 19th and early 20th centuries // Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities and Social Sciences. 2019. T. 12. № 6. S. 946–952.